Virginia is a Contributory Negligence Rule state, meaning, if you’ve been in an accident and you’ve contributed to causing the accident, even 1%, you can be found liable for the accident and your claim becomes moot.
For example, Ally crosses GW Parkway without looking both ways, stupidly trusting that no one would dare hit a pedestrian. Tom is driving home, messing with the music, texting Gale, playing with the temperature controls, and fixing his mirror, basically driving as negligently as possible. He hits Ally and she takes him to court.
The problem? The entire case is thrown out because the accident would not have happened had Ally not acted carelessly. It doesn’t matter that Tom was behaving negligently, because there is no proof that the accident would have happened without Ally’s poor decision. Ally contributed to her injuries and will pay the price for them.
This is what happens in a “Pure” Contributory Negligence state, which only applies to Alabama, the District of Columbia, Maryland, North Carolina, and Virginia. In all the other 46 states the plaintiff’s recovery is simply diminished by the extent to which he or she contributed to the harm, also known as comparative negligence.
Defense attorneys are constantly trying to catch plaintiffs in the act of contributing to their accidents. What may seem benign to you, “I changed the radio station right before she rear-ended me,” might be all a defense attorney needs to poke holes into your liability. Defense attorneys are trying to prove that the plaintiff acted recklessly, and was negligent in protecting their own safety.
DISCLAIMER: THIS IS NOT LEGAL ADVICE OR INSTRUCTION. MERELY AN INFORMATIVE POST.
-
5.0/5.0Justin Curcio and Curcio Law were outstanding in handling all aspects of my car accident. I’m very appreciative of the support they gave me and by making a bad situation into a seamless process.
-
5.0/5.0
The process was made easy by Justin Curcio. After the first meeting, he/his office handled everything only involving me once in a while when a decision was needed. A seamless process relieving me of much stress!
-
5.0/5.0
I can not put into words the amazing experience Tom and his team have done for our family. My daughter and I were involved in a terrible accident in 2021 that resulted in some serious injuries. From the very first encounter, Tom treated our case lik...
-
5.0/5.0
Tom was my attorney for a 3rd party personal injury (dog bite) that I experienced in 2021. He provided outstanding guidance & led my case to a very successful conclusion. I recommend Tom & his firm to anyone needing legal support. Thank you Tom, yo...
-
5.0/5.0
After an auto accident I needed a Personal Injury Lawyer. Curcio Law was recommended. Justin Curcio handled my case. He was meticulous in gathering information and at the hearing. I was treated with courtesy and caring all through the process. M...
